The Resistance Brief: A New Wave of Anti-LGBTQ+ Ballot Fights

Blog by Ricardo Martinez (he/him), Executive Director

A new wave of anti-LGBTQ+ ballot campaigns is building in states across the country. Campaigns targeting transgender youth are landing on ballots from Maine to Washington state. But LGBTQ+ people and our allies have faced coordinated ballot campaigns before, twice in fact, and both times, we came out the other side with more favorable judicial precedent than we had going in. 

The modern era of anti-LGBTQ+ ballot campaigns began in the 1990s. In 1992, Oregon and Colorado simultaneously ran statewide measures aimed at stripping civil rights protections based on sexual orientation. The framing was deliberately misleading: not anti-gay discrimination, but opposition to “special rights.” Oregon’s Measure 9 went further, seeking to brand homosexuality “abnormal” and “perverse” in the state constitution – and was defeated. Colorado’s Amendment 2, which banned protections outright, passed. The legal challenge reached the Supreme Court, which struck it down in Romer v. Evans. It was the first time the Court recognized equal protection rights for gay and lesbian people. 

A decade later, following GLAD Law’s court victory in Goodridge when Massachusetts legalized same-sex marriage in 2004, conservative political consultant Karl Rove helped orchestrate campaigns in 13 states to amend state constitutions to ban same-sex marriage. On Election Day 2004, all 13 measures passed. By 2008, 29 states had followed – and the LGBTQ+ movement looked like it was losing badly. 

But advocates didn’t stop. Litigation continued. Organizers built state-by-state infrastructure. And public opinion shifted faster than anyone predicted, as a younger generation grew up knowing LGBTQ+ people as neighbors, classmates, co-workers, and family members. By 2012, marriage equality was winning at the ballot box, and in 2015, Obergefell v. Hodges made it the law of the land nationwide.

Now we are in a third wave of anti-LGBTQ+ ballot fights. This time, the target is transgender people – specifically transgender youth.

​​​​In at least six states, campaigns are actively working to put anti-trans measures before voters – with Nebraska the latest to launch a signature drive. Four states have already cleared that hurdle: Missouri, Maine, Colorado, and Washington all have measures confirmed for the November 2026 ballot, with Nevada in active signature-gathering. Missouri’s ballot measure is primarily an abortion ban, with a prohibition on health care access for trans minors bundled in. That pairing is deliberate. Proponents of the measure hope the anti-trans provision significantly increases support for overturning the state’s constitutional right to reproductive freedom – rights Missouri voters themselves enshrined just two years ago. Anti-trans disinformation is being used as a lever to strip away other foundational rights.  

Every wave of anti-LGBTQ+ ballot campaigns has used the language of protection rather than exclusion, and each generation of anti-LGBTQ+ organizers has worked to sand down the edges, to make their discrimination harder to see. The 1990s campaigns called equality “special rights.” The 2004 marriage campaigns claimed to “protect traditional marriage.” Today’s measures claim to protect “girls’ sports” and “children.” The framing is designed to recruit voters who might not think of themselves as anti-LGBTQ+, but whose instinct to protect the vulnerable can be weaponized against the vulnerable.

There is also a legal strategy embedded in framing. In 1996, the Supreme Court struck down Colorado’s Amendment 2 – the “no special rights” measure from the 1990s wave in Romer v. Evans. The Court held that you cannot single out a group of people for disfavored treatment just because a majority dislike them. Bare animus, the Court said, is not a legitimate reason for a law.

The architects of today’s campaigns learned from that defeat. By attaching a “neutral” justification of competitive fairness in girls’ sports, they give courts something to point to other than animus. This is the same strategy that underpinned Skrmetti and the wave of restrictions from the federal administration and state legislatures: make these measures look like reasonable policy rather than targeted exclusion of a vulnerable minority. The ballot initiative campaigns are simply the latest front in that broader effort.

History offers a clear pattern: the emergence of a major anti-LGBTQ+ ballot wave has preceded, both times, a significant expansion of LGBTQ+ rights. The 1990s campaigns generated the legal infrastructure that led to Romer and then Lawrence, the Supreme Court ruling that overturned anti-gay sodomy laws. The 2004 wave forced a strategic reckoning that rebuilt the marriage equality movement from the ground up – and eleven years later, the movement had won at the Supreme Court.

What drove those turns? Litigation that never stopped. Strategic narrative work that helped shift public opinion faster than anyone predicted. Visibility in pop culture. Representation at all levels of government. And organizing infrastructure built and fortified in adversity. Lastly, opponents who overreached – whose measures, over time, revealed their true purpose.

The current moment is dangerous. If passed, these measures will harm real people regardless of how courts ultimately rule. The funding behind them: millions from megadonors like Brian Heywood in Washington and Richard Uihlein who is based in the Midwest but is the sole funder of the ballot initiative in Maine. And the “protecting girls” and “protecting children” frames are more calculated than “no special rights” was.

But our movement is stronger than it has ever been. The legal infrastructure is deeper, the organizing more sophisticated, and the coalition is broader. GLAD Law is part of that coalition – working with The Campaign for Free and Fair Schools to fight the Maine ballot initiative directly, bringing the same litigation strategy and movement infrastructure that has turned back anti-LGBTQ+ campaigns before including the successful effort to uphold transgender nondiscrimination protections at the ballot in Massachusetts in 2018. And there is a generation of young people, including trans young people, who are visible, and more organized. We are also in a moment where more Americans are waking up to what these campaigns are: a manufactured distraction. Attacking transgender people will not fix the economy, lower the cost of housing, ease lines at the airport, or make health care more affordable. The people funding these ballot campaigns know that. They are counting on voters not to.

Anti-LGBTQ+ forces have miscalculated before and lost. LGBTQ+ people came out the other side with more rights than we had going in. There is no reason to believe this time will be different. The question is not whether we, as a movement, will get through this. It is what we will build when we do.


What to know, what to do:

  • Check out Jennifer Levi on the TransLash podcast. She spoke with host Imara Jones about federal attacks on health care for transgender youth and how decades of legal advocacy prove one thing – fighting back works.
  • In an important win for families and providers, a federal judge struck down Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s attempt to impose sweeping health care restrictions on transgender youth. 
  • You can’t “take back” our families: read our recent piece in Boston Spirit Magazine addressing a new far-right anti-LGBTQ+ campaign and share your own family story. We have the power to counter fear and remind lawmakers what’s truly at stake: real children, real families, real lives. 
  • In two recent filings, GLAD Law led several organizations in urging the court to reject a Department of Education rule that could deny student loan forgiveness to people whose work the government labels as unlawful – including health care for transgender people – putting workers and organizations at risk. 
  • Contact your senator today and demand they vote NO on the SAVE Act. By requiring a passport or birth certificate to register to vote, this bill could strip voting rights from millions of eligible transgender Americans whose documents may not reflect their correct name or gender marker. This requirement would also disproportionately impact women and people of color. This isn’t election security – it’s voter suppression. 

Want to receive the Resistance Brief and other updates, action alerts, and event invitations in your email inbox?

Read more editions of the Resistance Brief.